Protostar Challenge 2026 · Climate Risk Intelligence
Will Everyone Endure the Heat?
Many U.S. cities face heat they were not built for, and the families least able to pay for cooling feel it first.
Team Unicorns · code and data on GitHub
Largest cities in need
Hover a dot for the city, its homes without AC, its hot days and its low-income bill.
Definitions
Two lines decide whether a home can endure the heat: what a family can afford, and what a body can bear.
“ A home is affordable when a household at the poverty line spends no more than 6% of its income keeping the power on, and livable when it stays at or below 82 °F inside. ”
APPRISE / ACEEE energy-burden line · U.S. rental cooling codes · CDC and WHO fan limits
By these lines, a low-income single person was already over the affordable share in 45 of 46 states before any warming.
Historical Data: Temperature
U.S. summers already run hotter than the grid was built for, and nights are warming fastest.
Trends
- Cooling degree days: +19% in the median city, 1976–2005 to the 2019–2025 forecast; up in 193 of 197 cities.
- Days with a high of 95 °F or more: +21%. Nights with a low of 75 °F or more: +48%.
Findings
- The rise lands where it is already hot: Texas, the Gulf Coast, the Southwest.
- Our forecast ran low against what happened, so these numbers are conservative.
Historical Data: Energy Use
Every 1 °F hotter day adds about 2% to peak electricity demand, in every U.S. region.
Trends
- U.S.: +13,700 MW of daily peak per 1 °F of the daily high (2.2%), summers 2015–2018.
- Most sensitive: Florida, 3.4% per °F. Least: the Northwest, 1.2%. Warmer nights lift the overnight floor about 1.5% per °F.
Findings
- Texas's longer record (2002–2018) agrees: 1.9% per °F.
- Four regions also peaked in winter in 2016–2018: grid risk runs both ways.
Historical Data: Energy Affordability
Before any warming, low-income electricity bills were already over the affordable line in 45 of 46 states.
Trends
- Real price rose from 11.8¢ (2002) to 12.8¢ per kWh (2018); the average home used about 11,000 kWh a year.
- Hotter years did not raise prices: −0.002¢ per 100 extra cooling degree days.
Findings
- Single person, low income: over the bar in 45 of 46 states. Family of four: 36 of 46.
- Worst where prices are high (New England, New York, California) or use is high (the South).
What the Three Datasets Tell Us
Hot summers raise how much power people use; what it costs follows fuel markets, not the weather.
Trends
- Year to year, a hotter summer means more use per home (r = 0.60 for year-to-year changes, 2002–2018).
- Price does not rise in hot years (r = −0.36); use per home drifted down after 2010 as appliances got more efficient.
Findings
- Unaffordability is structural: income, price and baseline use.
- Heat's cost lands on the grid at the peak, where reserves are planned on past weather.
Projected Numbers, 2019–2025
Summers keep getting hotter, but efficiency outpaces the extra cooling, and nothing in the record says prices will follow the heat.
Trends
- Weather: cooling degree days average 1,531 in 2019–2025, +8% on 2002–2018 (1,420).
- Use per home: the extra heat adds about 95 kWh a year (+0.9%), but the efficiency trend (−28 kWh a year) brings use down to about 10,700 kWh.
Findings
- Price is held at 2018's 12.8¢: in 2002–2018 it moved with fuel markets, not weather.
- So the average bill barely moves; the heat shows up at the peak and in the regions, not in the national average.
Regional Affordability, 2019–2025
Heat strain is regional, but unaffordability is everywhere: where it gets hotter is not where bills hurt most.
Cooling-required days a year
Low-income family bill ÷ affordable bar
Heat exposure against the bill, by state
Findings
- r: heat exposure barely predicts which states are unaffordable.
- A low-income family is over the bar in 36 of 46 states, from Maine to Texas.
- Forecast heat adds only $17–33 a year to the median low-income bill; its bigger cost is on the grid (Texas runs short in a hot summer).
Our forecast (data up to 2018), EIA-861, RECS 2015/2020, Census LACE, NERC 2018. 2018 dollars.
The Questions We Are Asking
Our forecast shows where today’s plans fall short. What to do about it is a choice for the people who hold each lever, so pick a role to see the question we hand them and the evidence behind it.
The risk we noticed
More very hot days and hot nights, and hotter afternoon peaks. Compared with 1976–2005, our 2019–2025 forecast has 21% more days of 95 °F or more and 48% more nights of 75 °F or more. The grid feels it at the peak; homes feel it where cooling is missing or costs too much to run.
Who they are: the groups that decide how much spare power the grid must keep ready for the hottest afternoons, and the utilities that build to meet it.
What we found
Grids are planned with a cushion of spare capacity, and that cushion was sized on past weather. By 2025 the warming we forecast uses up about a fifth of it. In a hot summer, Texas’s main grid falls 1.3% short of what people would want to use.
Demand on the hottest days climbs about 2% for every degree of extra heat, so small shifts in temperature matter more than they sound.
The questions we are asking
- Should the spare-capacity target be built on forecast weather instead of the weather of the past?
- How much extra margin is worth paying for, and where does it matter first?
- Is it cheaper to build more supply, or to shrink the peak by asking users to use less at that hour?
Where margins were already thin, the questions are the most urgent.
The evidence
- WeatherMore very hot days and hot nights are coming.
- Energy UseHow much more power each degree of heat costs the grid.
- Projected NumbersHow much of the cushion warming uses up.
- LimitationsWhat we could not measure about the grid.
Who they are: the state bodies that approve what electricity costs and how it is charged, and the power companies that bring those rules to life.
What we found
The problem with bills is not the heat. A low-income person living alone pays more than is considered affordable in 45 of 46 states, by about $300 a year. A low-income family of four is over the line in 36.
The extra heat we forecast adds only $17–33 a year. And in 2002–2018, hotter years did not push prices up; fuel markets moved them.
The questions we are asking
- Should what a household pays depend on what it earns, and not only on how much power it uses?
- Should usage rules protect people who cannot cut back, such as those who need cooling to stay safe?
- How should the cost of meeting the hottest hours be shared among customers?
Heat makes this old gap a little wider. It did not create it.
The evidence
- Energy AffordabilityWho pays more than they can afford, and how far over.
- Regional AffordabilityThe picture state by state, with and without extra heat.
- Combined ViewHeat and bills side by side.
- LimitationsWhy we hold prices at their 2018 level.
Who they are: the federal and state programs that help households pay their power bills, and the agencies that run efficiency upgrades for low-income homes.
What we found
Help with energy bills has long meant winter heating. Yet the same households struggle in summer, and the gap above the affordable line is large everywhere, not only in the hottest states: heat exposure barely predicts which states are worst off.
Making cooling in low-income homes use less power would ease the grid at its peak, lower the bill, and bring cooling to homes that have none.
The questions we are asking
- Should aid cover summer cooling as seriously as winter heating?
- Is paying for lasting efficiency upgrades a better use of money than paying each month’s bill?
- Which households and places should be served first?
Upgrades need money up front but cut the peak instead of paying for new power plants. That trade is theirs to weigh.
The evidence
- Energy AffordabilityThe size of the gap for low-income households.
- Regional AffordabilityHeat exposure does not line up with bill strain.
- Energy UseWhy a lower peak helps everyone.
Who they are: city and state officials who set housing standards, protect tenants, and run emergency response when heat is dangerous.
What we found
Homes fail in two different ways. In the North and West, many homes simply have no cooling: a third in Washington State, about a quarter in Maine and Montana.
In the South, nearly every home has it, but hot nights keep climbing (Florida from 69 to 96 a year, Texas from 46 to 75). There the risk is a bill too high to run it, or the power going out.
The questions we are asking
- Should renters be guaranteed a safe indoor temperature?
- Should power stay on for households during dangerous heat, even when a bill is unpaid?
- Where should public cooling places be, and when should they open?
The right mix differs by region, so one national rule would fit neither.
The evidence
- WeatherHot days and nights by place, past and forecast.
- DefinitionsWhat “safe to live in” means here.
- Regional AffordabilityWhich places can least afford to run cooling.
- LimitationsWhat our home-cooling data cannot tell us.
Our forecast (data up to 2018) and public energy, price and housing data from the federal government · 46 states, 2018 dollars · every number above is detailed in the linked slides
How We Will Answer It
One concrete proposal for each group, built so that each helps the others. Pick a role to see what it would do, who else it affects and what supports it.
Who acts: regional grid operators and the state bodies that approve utility plans.
Our proposal
- Plan the spare capacity for the hottest afternoons on forecast weather, not only past weather, by adding a warming allowance to each region’s summer peak estimate.
- Count peak-cutting as capacity: efficient cooling, and agreements to use less at the peak hour, should compete on equal terms with new power plants.
- Start where the cushion was already thin, such as Texas.
What it does for the other sides
- Households: fewer outages in a heat wave.
- Rate regulators: the allowance shows up in bills, so cutting the peak is the cheaper first move.
- Aid funders: efficient cooling in low-income homes becomes a source of capacity, not only a social program.
The evidence
- Auffhammer et al. 2017Peak demand is projected to grow faster than average use as it warms.
- IEA 2018More efficient cooling can cut the need for new power plants at the peak.
- Energy UseWhat each degree of heat costs the grid.
Who acts: the state bodies that approve electricity prices, and the power companies that apply them.
Our proposal
- Bring low-income bills down to the affordable line with an income-based discount, so no household pays more than about 6% of its income for home energy.
- Spread the cost across all customers, so it stays small for each one.
- Pair the discount with efficiency upgrades, so it can shrink over time.
What it does for the other sides
- Households: smaller bills, fewer shut-offs.
- Other customers: pay a little more, and gain a steadier grid.
- Utilities: fewer unpaid bills.
- Grid planners: the paired upgrades lower the peak.
The evidence
- Borenstein 2012Direct, income-based help wastes less than discounting through tiered prices.
- Energy AffordabilityHow far over the line low-income bills are.
- Regional AffordabilityWhere the gap is largest.
Who acts: the federal and state programs that help pay power bills, and the agencies that run efficiency upgrades.
Our proposal
- Treat summer cooling like winter heating: let aid help pay cooling bills, not only heating.
- Put part of the money into lasting upgrades for low-income homes (efficient heat pumps, insulation, sealing), starting with homes that have no cooling or very old equipment.
- Run small trials first and measure the real savings before scaling up.
What it does for the other sides
- Grid planners: a lower peak.
- Rate regulators: lower bills mean a smaller discount to fund.
- Cities: homes that had no cooling get it.
- Households: lower bills that stay lower.
The evidence
- Deetjen et al. 2021In 55 U.S. cities, heat pumps cut emissions damages in about 7 in 10 homes and saved money in about 1 in 3.
- Barreca et al. 2016Home air conditioning explains nearly all of the fall in heat deaths since 1960.
- Energy AffordabilityThe gap this money would target.
Who acts: city and state officials who set housing rules, protect tenants and run emergency response.
Our proposal
- Set a safe upper indoor temperature for rented homes. A limit near 82 °F is a starting point that local data can adjust.
- Keep the power on for households during dangerously hot days, working with the state body that sets utility rules.
- Open public cooling places on forecast hot days and hot nights, placed using our forecast.
What it does for the other sides
- Households: a safer home, and a safer night.
- Landlords: take on upgrade costs, which aid funders can help cover.
- Utilities: some bills are paid later, in exchange for fewer emergencies.
- Aid funders: a clear list of homes to reach first.
The evidence
- Barreca et al. 2016Where homes have cooling, very hot days kill far fewer people.
- WeatherHot days and nights by place.
- DefinitionsWhat “safe to live in” means here.
The thread that runs through all four
Use less power at the hottest hour. Efficient cooling in low-income homes cuts the peak the grid must meet, the bill a family must pay, and the number of homes with no cooling at all. Each group can start with powers it already has, and each proposal is built to help the others.
Proposals are ours; the numbers come from our forecast and public data · papers are cited in full on the last page of this section
The Drawbacks, and the Numbers We Still Need
No proposal is free. For each group, here is who else bears a cost, what the research warns, and what we must measure before anyone finalizes a decision.
Drawbacks and open numbers for this group’s proposal
Drawbacks, and who else bears them
- Planning on forecast weather raises costs sooner: customers pay for capacity that is needed only if the warming arrives.
- If it warms more slowly than forecast, the extra margin sits idle.
- Peak-cutting counts as capacity only if people really respond when asked.
Numbers we need to finalize
- How much extra capacity each region needs by 2025 and 2030, from our forecast.
- What that costs by building supply versus cutting the peak.
- How much peak cut efficient cooling and peak-hour agreements really deliver.
- How uncertain the forecast is, region by region.
What the research warns
- Davis et al. 2014Efficient refrigerators saved about a quarter of what was predicted, and replacing air conditioners raised power use in Mexico.
- Auffhammer et al. 2017Their peak estimates assume today’s technology and prices.
Drawbacks and open numbers for this group’s proposal
Drawbacks, and who else bears them
- Other customers pay more to fund the discount, and a bigger discount means a bigger share.
- Many eligible households never sign up, so part of the gap stays open.
- A flat discount can blur the price of power at the peak hour and weaken the push to use less then.
Numbers we need to finalize
- How many households sit above the affordable line in each state (we have the share, we need the count).
- The yearly cost of closing the gap: our median is about $300 a household, times those enrolled.
- What that adds to a typical customer’s bill.
- How many eligible households sign up in similar programs.
What the research warns
- Borenstein 2012California’s steepest tiered prices cut the lowest-income bills by only about 10%, at a large efficiency cost compared with direct transfers.
Drawbacks and open numbers for this group’s proposal
Drawbacks, and who else bears them
- Upgrades cost a lot up front, so fewer homes are helped this year than with bill help alone.
- Real savings can fall short of predictions.
- Heat pumps can raise heating bills in some homes, depending on the fuel they replace.
- Money spent on upgrades is not there for bill help in the hottest weeks.
Numbers we need to finalize
- Measured savings per home, by region, from small trials.
- Cost per home, and years to pay back.
- How many homes have no cooling or very old equipment, by state.
- How many homes a year the budget reaches under each mix of bill help and upgrades.
What the research warns
- Fowlie et al. 2018In Michigan, home upgrades cost about twice the value of the energy they saved. Critics note it left out non-energy benefits such as comfort and health.
- Deetjen et al. 2021Heat pumps saved money in only about a third of homes.
Drawbacks and open numbers for this group’s proposal
Drawbacks, and who else bears them
- Landlords carry the upgrade cost, and may raise rents or take homes off the market unless aid helps.
- Keeping power on in dangerous heat shifts some unpaid bills to other customers.
- Cooling places only help people who can reach them.
- A temperature limit needs inspections, which cities must pay for.
Numbers we need to finalize
- How many rented homes lack working cooling, by city.
- Upgrade cost per home, and the likely change in rent.
- How many hot nights each city should expect (our forecast has this for 210 stations).
- Which neighborhoods are farthest from a cooling place.
What the research warns
- Barreca et al. 2016Leaving homes without cooling is costly: it explains nearly all of the drop in hot-day deaths since 1960.
- Davis and Gertler 2015Whether a home has cooling depends heavily on income and climate.
Before any group decides
Every group needs the same three numbers: how big the problem is in their own place, what a fix costs per household or per unit of power, and what a small trial actually delivers. We would not scale any piece until the trial results are in.
Papers are cited in full on the last page of this section · “about $300 a year” is the median affordability gap across states, 2019–2025 forecast, 2018 dollars
Why It Lasts
A plan is sustainable if it helps now without making emissions or costs worse later. We think this one does, as long as the cooling is efficient.
Emissions
Cooling gets more efficient, not just bigger.
Cooling demand will climb as the world warms and more households install air conditioning (Davis and Gertler 2015). Efficiency is the biggest lever against that: strong efficiency policy could cut the world’s cooling energy use by 45% by 2050 compared with doing nothing (IEA 2018). In 55 U.S. cities, heat pumps reduced emissions damages in about 7 in 10 homes (Deetjen et al. 2021).
Could fail if the extra power comes from a dirty grid, or old equipment is swapped for a unit that is hardly better.
Costs
Cutting the peak is cheaper than building for it.
Under a high-warming path, peak demand is projected to grow about twice as fast as average use (Auffhammer et al. 2017), and the grid must be sized for the peak. Efficient cooling reduces the need for new power plants at that hour, and the same agency estimates it lowers total investment and running costs by about $3 trillion worldwide to 2050 (IEA 2018).
Could fail if savings come in below predictions: replaced refrigerators saved a quarter of the predicted amount (Davis et al. 2014), and Michigan home upgrades cost about twice the energy they saved (Fowlie et al. 2018). That is why trials come first.
Over the long run
Keeps cooling a safety net as hot days multiply.
Home air conditioning explains nearly all of the 75% fall in the death toll of very hot days in the U.S. since 1960 (Barreca et al. 2016). With more very hot days and nights coming, that protection holds only if homes have cooling, can afford to run it, and the grid stays on. The four proposals aim at exactly those three conditions.
Could fail if funding fades, or warming outruns the forecast. We would revisit the plan each year with new forecasts and trial results.
References
- Auffhammer, M., Baylis, P., & Hausman, C. H. (2017). Climate change is projected to have severe impacts on the frequency and intensity of peak electricity demand across the United States. PNAS, 114(8), 1886–1891.
- Barreca, A., Clay, K., Deschênes, O., Greenstone, M., & Shapiro, J. S. (2016). Adapting to climate change: The remarkable decline in the U.S. temperature-mortality relationship over the twentieth century. Journal of Political Economy, 124(1), 105–159.
- Borenstein, S. (2012). The redistributional impact of nonlinear electricity pricing. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 4(3), 56–90.
- Davis, L. W., & Gertler, P. J. (2015). Contribution of air conditioning adoption to future energy use under global warming. PNAS, 112(19), 5962–5967.
- Davis, L. W., Fuchs, A., & Gertler, P. (2014). Cash for coolers: Evaluating a large-scale appliance replacement program in Mexico. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 6(4), 207–238.
- Deetjen, T. A., Walsh, L., & Vaishnav, P. (2021). US residential heat pumps: the private economic potential and its emissions, health, and grid impacts. Environmental Research Letters, 16, 084024.
- Fowlie, M., Greenstone, M., & Wolfram, C. (2018). Do energy efficiency investments deliver? Evidence from the Weatherization Assistance Program. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 133(3), 1597–1644.
- International Energy Agency (2018). The Future of Cooling: Opportunities for energy-efficient air conditioning. Paris: IEA.
Figures are the authors’ own: 45%, $3 trillion and the fall in heat deaths are global or national, not city forecasts.
Limitations
Warming is a modest part of grid risk to 2025. Here is what we assumed, what our data cannot see, and what would change the answer.
Where the 2025 grid margin goes, median NERC area
Percentage points of reserve margin lost
What we assumed
- NERC’s 50/50 peak forecasts do not already include warming.
- Demand rises linearly with heat; the peak day’s high stands in for the peak hour.
- A higher price in scarcity is only a scenario: hot years did not raise prices in 2002–2018.
What our data cannot see
- No humidity: dry-heat thresholds understate risk in humid places.
- Airport stations miss city-centre heat; EIA-930 covers only 3.5 summers.
- RECS income brackets approximate poverty; Alaska and Hawaii are left out.
Outside our scope
- The cold side: four regions hit their yearly peak in winter in 2016–2018. Grid risk runs both ways.
- Load is what customers drew, so demand cut in emergencies does not show.
What would change the conclusion
Plans already include warming. Then the planning gap shrinks.
The poor cut cooling more. Likely: bills fall but homes get hotter, so livability is worse than shown.
Our forecast runs low. It was conservative on heat days, so warming’s effects are probably understated.
docs/policy_essay_outline.md §7 · outputs/grid_projection_national/summary.md · outputs/grid_national/summary.md
Reproducibility & Openness
One command rebuilds the submitted forecast byte for byte, and every number in this deck traces back to a script and a committed file.
1
The forecast
- No randomness: same data in, same file out. Package versions pinned in
requirements.txt. - Rebuilt from a clean copy of the repo: identical to
submission.csv(5,880 rows, SHA-256f1ba20cc…). - Training data pinned to revision
bbbdebda…inshared.py, so later dataset updates cannot change it.
pip install -r code/requirements.txt python code/exp05b_daily_distribution.py python code/check_submission.py submission.csv
Under a minute on a laptop.
2
This deck
- Challenge data to 2018 + EIA, NERC, RECS, Census LACE
policy_*.py: each writes its fixed settings toconfig.jsonbefore any resultoutputs/*/summary.mdand CSVs, all committedexport_deck_data.py→deck_data.js→ these slides
Every intermediate file is in the repo, so any step can be re-run on its own. Sources: data/README.md, data/policy_sources.md.
3
The data rule, in code
assert_cutoffstops any run that sees a year after 2018.- Each experiment's decision rule is written to
decision.jsonbefore its forecast. - 2019–2025 observations: used only to score frozen forecasts after the fact, declared in the README, and kept out of these slides.
- Agent rules in
code/AGENTS.md; every AI step is listed in the README.
Known gaps, stated up front
Raw downloads. Agency files for the policy analysis are cached in data/raw/, which is not committed; a full rebuild re-downloads them.
Census key. County matching needs a free Census API key. Its output is committed, so later steps run without one.
Old scores. Held-back cdd scores in Experiments 3–7 predate the valid_flags fix. Forecasts are unaffected.
Code, data and outputs: github.com/JessCai06/-Protostar-Challenge-CMU-2026-Climate-Risk-Intelligence · README “Reproduce”
Conclusion
Not everyone will endure the heat on plans built for yesterday’s weather.
Grids and household budgets are planned on past summers. Our forecast for 2019–2025, made only from data up to 2018, shows where that falls short.
+48%
The heat is uneven
Hot nights rise by half and cooling-required days by a fifth, mostly in Texas, the Gulf Coast and the Southwest. Nights warm faster than days.
⅕
The grid feels it first
Warming uses up about a fifth of the planned reserve cushion. ERCOT, already below its reference margin, runs short in a hot summer.
45 of 46
Bills were already too high
Low-income electricity bills were over the affordable bar in 45 of 46 states before any warming. Heat adds only $17–33 a year.
So
Plan reserves on forecast weather, fix affordability where it is structural, and bring cooling to homes that have none. One lever serves all three: efficient cooling for low-income homes, which lowers the peak, lowers the bill and makes homes livable.
Team Unicorns · Protostar Challenge 2026 · Code, data and the full essay: github.com/JessCai06/-Protostar-Challenge-CMU-2026-Climate-Risk-Intelligence